Vaseline has been my tried and tested and '100% never fails me' eye make up remover for life. Waterproof mascara, glue from false eyelashes, you name it, Vaseline gets it off. I'ts really easy on your skin and an old urban legend is that putting a tiny bit on your eyelashes before you go asleep helps them grow longer.
WIN WIN SITUATION! So no need to splash out on fancy eye make up remover when you can get your vaseline out of the press and give that a go!